John Elway Rookie Cards

Compare the defining rookie cards of John Elway—ranked through independent scores and supported by PSA population data.

3Cards profiled

87Highest score

1984Rookie era

Top card87Hobby Score

Compare the collection

John Elway Cards, Ranked

Every card uses the same four-part scoring framework. Open any card for its full case, badges, population history, and collector vote.

Hobby Score87

1984 Topps #63

PSA 10190

PSA 93,177

PSA 812,106

Total graded33,454

Explore this card →

Hobby Score79

1985 Topps #238

PSA 1021

PSA 9167

PSA 81,179

Total graded3,050

Explore this card →

Hobby Score81.5

1986 Topps #112

PSA 1038

PSA 9527

PSA 81,625

Total graded3,515

Explore this card →

Population data powered byPop counts last updated: July 2026